Enter Your Reply

And yes I would rate many medieval chesses and old shogis poor because of too many different pieces types with not enough clarity. But Jeppsereiwan pieces are even more inelegant than those because of two types of divergence. And if it is inappropriate to rate a game poor when that is what you think then editors should remove that option. I rated game poor based on unoriginality (minor downgrade of existing games) and inelegance of new pieces. If editors want a 'don't say anything if you can't say nice' website that is their decision. But then you will see too many new low quality variants (there are too many already, some inventors think every impulse is great new variant).