The following are readers' comments and ratings for the page Knot Chess.
| Date | Rating | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 4 Jul 2001 | Poor | There is one major difference between Circular Chess and Knot Chess --- Circular is playable. (If you look at the initial piece placement in Knot Chess, you'll see the Black King is threatened by the White King, Queen and King's side Bishop, and King's side Knight.) |
| 4 Jul 2001 | None | A reader wrote: How is knot chess really any different from circular chess? The boards may look differently, but their structures must end up being the same; that is, files running in cycles, while ranks are bounded. The two games must be, to use mathematical language, isomorphic. The difference is merely aesthetical. The same game could also be played out on an ordinary chessboard by simply considering the two ends glued together. -- I think this is correct. |
| 16 May 2001 | Poor | Movement on this board needs to be explained. |
| 3 May 2001 | Poor | Very unoriginal. Was this a play on words or something? |
| 3 Sep 2000 | None | Dear Lord, that's just wrong. |
Last modified: Sunday, April 1, 2012
